The most commonly sung song in the English language is “Happy Birthday to You.” The second is “Silent Night.” That one fact tells you almost everything about how deeply Christmas has embedded itself into the culture. Not commerce, not religion. Music. We sing it before we think about it. And the things we do without thinking are exactly the things we get wrong in trivia.
The person searching for christmas trivia questions right now is probably hosting something. A party, a family gathering, a work event where they need to fill twenty minutes without anyone checking their email. They know the surface stuff. They’ve seen the movies a hundred times. They think they know the songs. They’re wrong about at least three things they’d bet money on, and I know which three because I’ve watched it happen in real time, year after year, in rooms full of people wearing ugly sweaters and holding drinks they didn’t pay for.
These 50 questions are sequenced the way I’d run them live. Some warm you up. Some make you feel smart. And some are designed to make the most confident person at your table go very, very quiet.
The Ones You Think You Know
1. How many reindeer pull Santa’s sleigh in the poem “A Visit from St. Nicholas”?
Everyone wants to say nine. Everyone. I’ve seen entire teams commit to nine with absolute certainty, and then the slow realization spreads across the table like a spill.
Show Answer
Eight. Rudolph wasn’t invented until 1939 by Robert L. May for a Montgomery Ward coloring book. The original 1823 poem names eight: Dasher, Dancer, Prancer, Vixen, Comet, Cupid, Donner, and Blitzen. The most common wrong answer is nine, because Rudolph feels like he’s always been there. He hasn’t.
2. What country started the tradition of putting up a Christmas tree?
This one’s a layup to get people feeling good. Let them have it.
Show Answer
Germany. The tradition dates to the 16th century, and it was Prince Albert, Queen Victoria’s German husband, who popularized it in England in the 1840s.
3. In the song “Twelve Days of Christmas,” what is given on the seventh day?
I’ve never once seen a room get this on the first try without someone humming through all twelve days out loud. The middle days are a black hole.
Show Answer
Seven swans a-swimming. Most people guess geese (that’s six) or maids (that’s eight). The brain just can’t hold the middle of that song without the melody doing the work.
4. What’s the best-selling Christmas song of all time?
This generates arguments every single time because people confuse “best-selling” with “most played” or “most iconic.” They’re not the same list.
Show Answer
“White Christmas” by Bing Crosby, with estimated sales over 50 million copies. The common wrong answer now is Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You,” which is the most streamed, but in total sales, Bing still wins by a mile.
5. What color are the berries on a mistletoe plant?
Simple question. Brutal results. People picture holly and mistletoe as the same thing.
Show Answer
White. Holly has the red berries. Mistletoe berries are white and, worth knowing, toxic. The mix-up is almost universal because red and green are Christmas colors and the brain just fills in what it expects.
6. Which country is credited with the tradition of leaving shoes out for presents instead of stockings?
A nice breather that teaches something. Nobody argues about this one, but everyone remembers it.
Show Answer
The Netherlands (and several other European countries, but the Dutch tradition of leaving shoes out for Sinterklaas is the most well-known origin).
The Movie Round Nobody Aces
7. In “Home Alone,” where are the McCallisters going on vacation when they leave Kevin behind?
This one separates the people who’ve seen it from the people who’ve watched it.
Show Answer
Paris. Not Hawaii, not London. Paris. And somehow people who’ve seen this movie thirty times still hesitate.
8. What’s the name of the main character in “The Nightmare Before Christmas”?
Easy, right? But I include it because it leads beautifully into the next one.
Show Answer
Jack Skellington.
9. Who directed “The Nightmare Before Christmas”?
And here’s where the room splits. This is the single most confidently wrong answer I’ve ever witnessed in a Christmas trivia round. People will argue with you after you give them the answer.
Show Answer
Henry Selick. Not Tim Burton. Burton produced it and created the characters, but Selick directed it. Burton was busy directing “Batman Returns” and then “Ed Wood” during production. I have literally had someone pull out their phone to prove me wrong, only to go silent. The film’s full title is “Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas,” which is honestly unfair to everyone.
10. In the movie “Elf,” what are the four main food groups according to Buddy?
People can usually get three. The fourth one trips them up every time.
Show Answer
Candy, candy canes, candy corns, and syrup.
11. What fictional town is the setting for “It’s a Wonderful Life”?
A warm one. The kind of question that makes people smile when they answer it.
Show Answer
Bedford Falls.
12. In “A Christmas Story,” what does Ralphie want for Christmas?
If someone doesn’t know this, they’ve lived a very different December than the rest of us.
Show Answer
A Red Ryder carbine-action 200-shot range model air rifle. Bonus points if anyone at your table can recite the full name without pausing.
13. What year was “A Charlie Brown Christmas” first broadcast?
People always guess later than the actual date. The animation style throws them. It feels like it could be from any era.
Show Answer
1965. CBS executives reportedly hated it before it aired. They thought the jazz soundtrack was wrong, the pacing was too slow, and using actual children’s voices instead of adults was a mistake. It was watched by nearly half of all American television viewers that night.
14. In “Die Hard,” what is the name of the building the terrorists take over?
Yes, we’re counting it as a Christmas movie. I’m not reopening that debate. I’ve lost friends.
Show Answer
Nakatomi Plaza.
15. What Christmas movie features the line, “The best way to spread Christmas cheer is singing loud for all to hear”?
People either know this instantly or they attribute it to about four different movies in rapid succession.
Songs That Trip You Up
16. In “Jingle Bells,” what kind of sleigh is mentioned?
This is one of those questions where the answer is literally in the lyrics and people still blank on it.
Show Answer
A one-horse open sleigh.
17. “Jingle Bells” was originally written for which holiday?
And now the follow-up that makes the whole room lean in.
Show Answer
Thanksgiving. James Lord Pierpont wrote it in 1857, and the original title was “One Horse Open Sleigh.” It was composed for a Thanksgiving church program. There’s nothing in the lyrics about Christmas at all, if you actually read them.
18. Who wrote “The Christmas Song” (“Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire”)?
People always guess the performer. The writer is the surprise.
Show Answer
Mel Tormé and Bob Wells. They wrote it during a heat wave in July 1945. Tormé said Wells had started jotting down wintry images to try to cool off, and they turned them into a song in about 45 minutes. The most common wrong answer is Nat King Cole, who recorded the most famous version but didn’t write it.
19. What Christmas carol includes the lyric “Don we now our gay apparel”?
Easy question, but it always gets a laugh. I include it for the room’s energy, not the difficulty.
Show Answer
“Deck the Halls.”
20. In “Frosty the Snowman,” what brings Frosty to life?
Kids get this faster than adults. Adults overthink it.
Show Answer
An old silk hat. Not a magic hat. Not a top hat. An old silk hat they found. The specificity is right there in the song and people still say “a magic hat” like it’s a fairy tale.
21. “Do They Know It’s Christmas?” was recorded by Band Aid to raise money for famine relief in which country?
People know it was Africa. They don’t always know the specific country.
Show Answer
Ethiopia. The 1984 famine. Bob Geldof organized the recording, which led to Live Aid the following year.
22. What was the first Christmas song broadcast from space?
This is one of my favorite questions to ask because nobody expects it to have an answer at all.
Show Answer
“Jingle Bells.” On December 16, 1965, Gemini 6 astronauts Wally Schirra and Tom Stafford smuggled a harmonica and sleigh bells aboard and performed it after reporting a UFO sighting (Santa’s sleigh). NASA was not amused. Then they were.
History and Traditions (Where Confidence Goes to Die)
23. In what century was the celebration of Christmas on December 25th first recorded?
People either guess way too early or way too late. Almost nobody lands in the right century.
Show Answer
The 4th century (336 AD is the first recorded date). The Bible doesn’t specify a date for Jesus’s birth, and scholars have debated for centuries why December 25th was chosen. The leading theory connects it to the Roman festival of Saturnalia and the winter solstice.
24. Which U.S. state was the last to declare Christmas a legal public holiday?
People guess a southern state or a New England state. They’re wrong on both counts.
Show Answer
Oklahoma, in 1907. Though to be fair, it became a state that same year, so it declared Christmas a holiday essentially immediately. If you want the more interesting answer, Christmas wasn’t declared a federal holiday until 1870, and several states held out for decades before that.
25. What plant, traditionally used in Christmas decorations, is actually a parasite?
The word “parasite” always gets a reaction. People kiss under a parasite every year.
Show Answer
Mistletoe. It’s a hemiparasite, meaning it attaches to host trees and steals water and nutrients from them while still doing some of its own photosynthesis. Romantic.
26. In which country did the tradition of Christmas crackers originate?
Americans often don’t know what these are. Brits can’t imagine Christmas without them.
Show Answer
England. Tom Smith, a London confectioner, invented them in the 1840s, inspired by French bonbons wrapped in twists of paper.
27. What did the Puritans do to Christmas in England in 1647?
This one always lands hard. People don’t believe it.
Show Answer
They banned it. Oliver Cromwell and the Puritan parliament outlawed Christmas celebrations, considering them too indulgent and lacking biblical authority. The ban lasted until the Restoration in 1660. Soldiers were sent to patrol streets and confiscate food being prepared for Christmas feasts.
28. The image of Santa Claus in a red suit was popularized by advertisements for which company in the 1930s?
Everyone knows this one. Or thinks they do. The real story is more complicated than the trivia answer, but the trivia answer is what you need.
Show Answer
Coca-Cola. Artist Haddon Sundblom created the iconic images starting in 1931. Now, Coca-Cola didn’t invent the red suit. Santa appeared in red before that. But Coke’s campaign standardized the image so thoroughly that everything before it basically got erased from public memory.
29. What is frankincense?
One of the three gifts of the Magi, and I’d estimate about 70% of people couldn’t tell you what it actually is if you put a gun to their head.
Show Answer
A resin (dried tree sap) from the Boswellia tree, burned as incense. It was incredibly valuable in the ancient world, sometimes worth more than gold by weight. Myrrh is also a tree resin, which means two of the three gifts were essentially tree sap.
30. What is the day after Christmas called in the UK, Australia, and Canada?
Most Americans know this. But ask them why it’s called that, and you’ll get silence.
Show Answer
Boxing Day. The name likely comes from the tradition of giving boxes of gifts or money to servants and tradespeople the day after Christmas. Not from the sport.
Around the World in Eight Questions
31. In Japan, what fast-food chain has become a wildly popular Christmas Eve dinner tradition?
This is one of those facts that sounds made up and is completely, wonderfully true.
Show Answer
KFC. The “Kurisumasu ni wa Kentakkii” (Kentucky for Christmas) campaign started in 1974 and became so successful that families now pre-order their Christmas KFC meals weeks in advance. Lines wrap around the building.
32. In which country do children leave their shoes by the fireplace for Père Noël to fill?
A gentle one after the KFC revelation.
33. What Central European tradition involves a horned, demonic figure who punishes naughty children during the Christmas season?
Everyone’s heard of this by now, but not everyone can name it correctly.
Show Answer
Krampus. He’s St. Nicholas’s dark companion in Austrian, Bavarian, and other Alpine traditions. The Krampuslauf (Krampus Run) on December 5th involves people in elaborate demon costumes chasing others through the streets. It’s exactly as terrifying as it sounds.
34. In Iceland, how many “Yule Lads” visit children in the 13 nights before Christmas?
The answer is in the question if you’re paying attention. But the details are what make this worth asking.
Show Answer
Thirteen. Each one arrives on a different night and has a specific, often mischievous personality. Their names include Spoon-Licker, Door-Slammer, and Sausage-Swiper. Their mother is a troll named Grýla who eats naughty children. Iceland doesn’t mess around.
35. In which country is it traditional to hide all brooms on Christmas Eve to prevent witches from stealing them?
This is the kind of question where the answer doesn’t even matter. The question itself is the gift.
Show Answer
Norway. The tradition is rooted in the old belief that Christmas Eve is when evil spirits and witches come out. So Norwegians hide their brooms. Just in case.
36. In Australia, what’s the weather typically like on Christmas Day?
I include this because Americans consistently forget that the Southern Hemisphere exists.
Show Answer
Hot. It’s summer in Australia during December. Christmas barbecues on the beach are standard. Santa sometimes arrives on a surfboard.
37. In Mexico, what is the name for the traditional Christmas Eve celebration?
A lot of people know the word but can’t quite pull it out of memory when the pressure’s on.
Show Answer
Nochebuena, which translates to “Good Night” or “Holy Night.” It’s often a bigger celebration than Christmas Day itself.
38. In Ethiopia, Christmas is celebrated on January 7th. What is the Ethiopian name for Christmas?
Almost nobody outside the Ethiopian community gets this. It’s a genuine stumper, and it’s here to keep the know-it-alls humble.
Show Answer
Ganna (sometimes spelled Genna). The Ethiopian Orthodox Church follows the Julian calendar, which is why the date differs. A traditional game similar to hockey, also called ganna, is played on the day.
Food and Drink (The Round That Makes People Hungry)
39. What is the main flavor of a candy cane?
Easy. But it sets up the next one.
40. What traditional Christmas drink is made with milk, cream, sugar, and eggs?
Everyone knows this. The question is whether they know what’s actually in it.
Show Answer
Eggnog. And if you’ve only ever had the store-bought version, you’ve never actually had eggnog. The real thing, made with raw eggs and a dangerous amount of bourbon, is a completely different experience.
41. What dried fruit is traditionally found in a Christmas pudding and associated with good luck when stirred into the mix?
Trick element here. It’s not the fruit that brings the luck. It’s the stirring. But people focus on the fruit anyway.
Show Answer
Raisins (and currants and sultanas). But the luck tradition is actually about the stirring. Everyone in the household stirs the pudding mixture and makes a wish. A silver coin hidden inside brings luck to whoever finds it in their serving. Ideally before they bite down on it.
42. What sweet treat is traditionally left out for Santa on Christmas Eve in the United States?
A palate cleanser. Sometimes you need one.
Show Answer
Cookies (and milk). In other countries the traditions vary wildly. Irish children leave Guinness. Australian kids leave beer. In Sweden, it’s rice porridge.
43. What spice gives gingerbread its distinctive dark color?
People say ginger. It’s in the name. But ginger doesn’t do what they think it does.
Show Answer
Molasses (technically not a spice, but the dark color comes from molasses, not ginger). If you want a spice answer, cinnamon and cloves contribute more to the color than ginger does. Ginger provides flavor and a bit of warmth but it’s pale on its own.
The Bible Questions (Where Everyone Gets Quiet)
44. How many wise men does the Bible say visited Jesus?
I save this one for when the room is feeling confident. It’s a trapdoor.
Show Answer
The Bible doesn’t say. Seriously. Matthew’s Gospel mentions wise men (Magi) bringing three gifts, which is where the assumption of three wise men comes from. But the actual number is never specified. It could have been two. It could have been twenty. I’ve watched deeply religious people stare at me in genuine shock over this one.
45. In what city was Jesus born, according to the Bible?
Easy. But after the last question, people suddenly don’t trust themselves.
46. What angel told Mary she would give birth to Jesus?
About half the room gets this. The other half is thinking of the wrong angel.
Show Answer
Gabriel. Michael is the other angel people guess, but Michael is traditionally the warrior angel. Gabriel is the messenger.
The Final Stretch
47. What is the Grinch’s dog’s name?
A warm-up for the finish. Everyone exhales on this one.
48. The poinsettia plant is native to which country?
People guess all over the map. Literally.
Show Answer
Mexico. Joel Roberts Poinsett, the first U.S. Ambassador to Mexico, brought the plant to the United States in 1828. The Aztecs called it “cuetlaxochitl” and used it to make red dye and treat fevers.
49. What astronomical event is the “Star of Bethlehem” most commonly theorized to have been?
Astronomers and theologians have been arguing about this for centuries. Your table can have five minutes with it.
Show Answer
A conjunction of Jupiter and Saturn (in 7 BC) is the most widely cited astronomical theory, though a comet, a nova, and a supernova have all been proposed. Some scholars argue it was purely miraculous and not an astronomical event at all. There is no consensus. There probably never will be.
50. The original lyrics to “Silent Night” were written in what language?
I close with this one every year. It’s not the hardest question in the set. It’s not a trick. But something about it lands differently at the end of the night, after everyone’s been laughing and arguing and getting things wrong and right for an hour. The answer comes, and the room goes a little quiet, and someone usually starts humming it. I’ve seen it happen at dive bars and living rooms and office break rooms. The song does something that fifty questions about Christmas can’t quite do. It reminds people why they showed up in the first place.
Show Answer
German. “Stille Nacht” was written by Joseph Mohr in 1816 and set to music by Franz Xaver Gruber in 1818 in Oberndorf bei Salzburg, Austria. The church organ had broken, so Gruber arranged it for guitar. A song born from a broken instrument in a small Austrian village became the most translated Christmas carol in the world. Over 300 languages and counting.
General knowledge is the hardest round to write because it has to be genuinely broad. I've been at it for 5 years from Denver, CO and I still approach every question like I'm writing for a room full of different people, because I am. I've written for JetPunk trivia, and I take the same care with every set I write.
Latest posts by Robert Taylor
(see all)