Before You Start Humming
“White Christmas” has sold more copies than any single recording in history, and Irving Berlin wrote it in a hotel room in warm weather, reportedly hating every second of the Los Angeles sunshine outside his window. That tension , between the song and the moment it was made , runs through almost every Christmas song worth knowing. They were written in July, recorded in August, fought over by executives who didn’t believe in them. The mythology around these songs is half the fun.
I’ve run christmas song trivia for years, and one thing never changes: people are absolutely certain they know the lyrics, absolutely certain they know who sang what first, and absolutely wrong about half of it. That confidence is what makes this category electric in a room. These 60 questions are built from that energy , the ones that make tables argue, the ones that make someone quietly mouth the lyrics to themselves before answering, and the ones where the right answer genuinely changes how you hear the song next December.
The Ones You Think You Know
1. In “Jingle Bells,” what kind of sleigh is mentioned in the first verse?
I love opening with this because everyone’s already singing it in their head. And almost nobody remembers the actual lyric until they hear the answer.
Show Answer
A one-horse open sleigh. Most people say “one-horse” without hesitation, but a surprising number pause and wonder if it’s “one-horse” or just “open.” It’s both , “a one-horse open sleigh.”
2. “Jingle Bells” wasn’t originally written for Christmas. What holiday was it composed for?
This is the question that makes people look at you like you’re lying. I’ve had someone pull out their phone mid-round to verify it.
Show Answer
Thanksgiving. James Lord Pierpont wrote it in 1857 for a Thanksgiving church program. It migrated to Christmas later because, well, sleigh bells.
3. What gift is given on the first day of Christmas in “The Twelve Days of Christmas”?
Warm-up pitch. But it sets up the harder ones later.
Show Answer
A partridge in a pear tree.
4. In “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer,” what activity are the other reindeer said to have excluded Rudolph from?
People rush to say “games” and they’re right. But the specific phrasing matters if you’re being precise.
Show Answer
“Any reindeer games.” Not just games , reindeer games, specifically. The phrase has entered the language so completely that people forget it came from a song written for a Montgomery Ward coloring book promotion in 1939.
5. Who wrote “White Christmas”?
If your table doesn’t know this one, you know where you stand for the rest of the night.
Show Answer
Irving Berlin. A Jewish immigrant from Russia who wrote what became the best-selling single of all time. That fact alone is worth sitting with for a moment.
6. What Christmas song contains the lyric “Everyone dancing merrily in the new old-fashioned way”?
This one separates people who listen to Christmas songs from people who just have them on in the background.
Show Answer
“Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” by Brenda Lee. The phrase “new old-fashioned way” is a beautiful little contradiction that most people have sung without ever really hearing.
7. How old was Brenda Lee when she recorded “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree”?
This is the one that gets audible gasps. Every single time.
Show Answer
13 years old. She recorded it in 1958. It didn’t become a major hit until 1960, and it’s been climbing charts ever since , it finally hit #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 2023, sixty-five years after she recorded it as a teenager.
8. In “Frosty the Snowman,” what item brings Frosty to life?
Quick breather. Let people feel smart before the next one takes it away.
Show Answer
An old silk hat. Not a top hat, not a magic hat , an old silk hat they found.
9. What two words does Frosty the Snowman say when the hat is placed on his head?
People know this one in their bones. It’s muscle memory from childhood.
Show Answer
“Happy birthday!” There’s something wonderfully weird about a snowman’s first words being about a completely different celebration.
10. “Santa Claus Is Comin’ to Town” warns children that Santa is making a list. What is he doing to that list?
Tables always shout the answer in unison on this one. It’s a good energy check.
Show Answer
Checking it twice. “He’s making a list, checking it twice, gonna find out who’s naughty or nice.”
Where Confidence Gets Dangerous
11. In “Winter Wonderland,” what is the name given to the snowman the couple builds?
I’ve watched grown adults freeze on this one. You’ve sung it a hundred times. What’s his name?
Show Answer
Parson Brown. “In the meadow we can build a snowman, then pretend that he is Parson Brown.” A surprising number of people say “Pastor Brown” or just stare blankly. The updated version of the song changes it to “Circus clown,” which doesn’t help the confusion.
12. What Christmas song was the first to be broadcast from space?
This one always produces creative guesses. People love guessing on this.
Show Answer
“Jingle Bells.” Astronauts Tom Stafford and Wally Schirra performed it aboard Gemini 6A in December 1965, using a smuggled harmonica and sleigh bells.
13. What does “Feliz Navidad” literally translate to in English?
Easy, right? Except I’ve had people say “Happy New Year” with total conviction because the song also mentions “prospero año nuevo.”
Show Answer
“Merry Christmas.” José Feliciano wrote it in 1970, deliberately keeping it simple so it could cross language barriers. It worked.
14. In “Baby, It’s Cold Outside,” what drink does the host offer the guest?
The song’s been debated endlessly in recent years, but the drink question still stumps people.
Show Answer
The guest asks “Say, what’s in this drink?” after being offered a drink, but the specific drink mentioned earlier is half a drink more. The host offers various drinks, but the one that gets the most attention in the lyric is when the guest says “maybe just a half a drink more.” Many people confidently say “eggnog” or “wine,” but the song never specifies the type. Common wrong answer: eggnog, because of the Christmas association.
15. Who originally recorded “Baby, It’s Cold Outside” , and what was the occasion?
This one reframes the entire song for people who only know the controversy.
Show Answer
Frank Loesser wrote it in 1944 and performed it as a duet with his wife, Lynn Garland, at a housewarming party. It was their party trick. She was reportedly furious when he sold it to MGM because it had been “their song.”
16. What is the best-selling Christmas single of all time?
Two answers will dominate any room. One is right.
Show Answer
“White Christmas” by Bing Crosby, with estimated sales exceeding 50 million copies worldwide. People always want to say Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You,” which is the most-streamed, but in terms of total sales across all formats, Bing still holds the crown.
17. In “The Christmas Song” (“Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire”), what are “tiny tots” doing?
You’re singing it right now. Go ahead, commit to an answer.
Show Answer
They have “their eyes all aglow.” The next line is the one people usually remember more: “They find it hard to sleep tonight.” But the question asks what they’re doing, and the answer is having their eyes aglow , which, honestly, is just a lovely image.
18. Who co-wrote “The Christmas Song” and in what unlikely weather conditions?
This is the one that makes people rethink everything about how Christmas songs get made.
Show Answer
Mel Tormé and Bob Wells wrote it during a blistering hot July day in 1945. Wells had started jotting down wintry images to try to cool himself down, and Tormé saw the notes and turned them into a song in about 45 minutes.
19. In “Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!” , is snow actually wanted by the singer?
This is a trick question disguised as a simple one, and it splits rooms right down the middle.
Show Answer
Not really. The song is about not wanting to go out into the storm , the singer is cozy inside with someone. “But the fire is so delightful” and “as long as you love me so” suggest the snow is just an excuse to stay put. Also, like “The Christmas Song,” it was written during a heat wave , by Sammy Cahn and Jule Styne in Hollywood, July 1945.
20. What Christmas song includes the lyric “Said the night wind to the little lamb”?
The opening line is iconic, but people don’t always connect it to the title.
Show Answer
“Do You Hear What I Hear?” Written in 1962 by Noël Regney and Gloria Shayne Baker as a plea for peace during the Cuban Missile Crisis. Knowing that changes how the song sounds.
The Pop Era Round
21. What year was Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You” released?
People always think it’s older than it is. Or newer. It lives in a weird temporal pocket.
Show Answer
1994. It was released on her album “Merry Christmas.” It didn’t reach #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 until 2019, twenty-five years after its release. Common wrong answer: people often guess late ’80s because of the production style, or early 2000s because that’s when it became truly inescapable.
22. How long did it take Mariah Carey and Walter Afanasieff to write “All I Want for Christmas Is You”?
The answer to this one makes professional songwriters either furious or inspired.
Show Answer
About 15 minutes. Carey has said in interviews that the melody and lyrics came together almost immediately. The recording took longer, obviously, but the bones of the song that now earns an estimated $2.5 million in royalties every holiday season came together in a quarter of an hour.
23. Which member of Wham! wrote “Last Christmas”?
People know Wham! sang it. But which one wrote it?
Show Answer
George Michael. He wrote, produced, and arranged it. Andrew Ridgeley was the other half of Wham! but had no writing credit on this track. George Michael donated all his royalties from the song to Ethiopian famine relief.
24. “Last Christmas” by Wham! was kept from the #1 spot in the UK upon its 1984 release by what other charity Christmas single?
This is one of those beautiful collisions in music history.
Show Answer
“Do They Know It’s Christmas?” by Band Aid , which George Michael also sang on. He was essentially competing against himself for the Christmas #1.
25. Who wrote “Do They Know It’s Christmas?”
People usually get one of the two writers. Getting both is the challenge.
Show Answer
Bob Geldof and Midge Ure. Geldof gets most of the public credit, but Ure did much of the musical composition and production.
26. What was the original title Mariah Carey considered for her Christmas album before settling on “Merry Christmas”?
This is a deep cut. Only real Mariah scholars get it.
Show Answer
Trick question , the album was always called “Merry Christmas.” I include this because it’s good to keep people honest. Not every question has a surprising answer. Sometimes the straightforward thing is true and the instinct to overthink is the trap.
27. In the song “Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer,” what was Grandma doing before her unfortunate encounter?
A novelty song, sure. But it’s been a staple since 1979 and the details are hazier than people think.
Show Answer
She was walking home from their house on Christmas Eve. She’d been drinking too much eggnog and they’d begged her not to go. The song is darker than people remember.
28. Paul McCartney’s “Wonderful Christmastime” , love it or hate it , was recorded using what then-cutting-edge instrument?
People have strong feelings about this song. The answer explains why it sounds the way it does.
Show Answer
A Sequential Circuits Prophet-5 synthesizer. McCartney recorded the entire song essentially by himself in 1979, layering synthesizer parts. That synth-heavy production is exactly why some people find it grating and others find it charming. It earns McCartney an estimated $400,000-$600,000 every December.
29. What Christmas song by The Pogues features a famous duet and was once voted the best Christmas song of all time in multiple UK polls?
If someone at your table starts singing it, let them. It’s that kind of song.
Show Answer
“Fairytale of New York,” featuring Shane MacGowan and Kirsty MacColl. It’s reached the UK Top 20 almost every December since its 1987 release without ever actually hitting #1 , the most beloved song that never topped the chart.
30. What city is the setting of “Fairytale of New York”?
The title gives it away, right? But the opening line places us somewhere more specific.
Show Answer
New York City, specifically beginning in “the drunk tank” on Christmas Eve. The song references Broadway and the NYPD choir, painting a very specific, very un-sentimental picture of the city at Christmas.
The Sacred and the Old
31. “Silent Night” was originally written in what language?
Most people get this. The follow-up is where it gets interesting.
Show Answer
German. “Stille Nacht, heilige Nacht” was written in 1818 by Franz Xaver Gruber (music) and Joseph Mohr (lyrics) in Oberndorf bei Salzburg, Austria.
32. According to popular legend, why was “Silent Night” originally performed with guitar instead of organ?
This is one of those stories that might be embellished, but it’s too good not to ask about.
Show Answer
The church organ had broken down (some versions say mice had eaten through the bellows). So Gruber composed the melody for guitar to accompany Mohr’s poem at the Christmas Eve service. Whether the mouse story is true is debated, but the guitar part is real.
33. What is the oldest known Christmas hymn still commonly sung today?
This one generates wild guesses. People reach for “O Come, All Ye Faithful” or “Silent Night” and they’re not even close.
Show Answer
“O Come, O Come, Emmanuel.” Its Latin text dates back to at least the 8th or 9th century, though the melody commonly used today was published in the 15th century. It’s been sung in some form for over a thousand years.
34. “O Holy Night” holds a unique distinction in broadcasting history. What is it?
This is one of my favorite pieces of Christmas song trivia because it connects music to technology in a way nobody expects.
Show Answer
It’s believed to be one of the first songs ever broadcast on radio. On Christmas Eve 1906, Canadian inventor Reginald Fessenden transmitted a recording of “O Holy Night” (which he played on violin) to ships at sea, in what’s considered one of the first AM radio broadcasts.
35. “Hark! The Herald Angels Sing” uses a melody adapted from a piece by what famous classical composer?
Classical music fans perk up on this one. Everyone else takes a swing.
Show Answer
Felix Mendelssohn. The melody was adapted from his cantata “Festgesang,” which he wrote to commemorate the 400th anniversary of the Gutenberg printing press. Mendelssohn himself said the melody would never suit sacred words. He was, by most accounts, wrong.
36. In “We Three Kings,” what are the three gifts brought by the Magi?
Sunday school kids nail this instantly. Everyone else gets two out of three.
Show Answer
Gold, frankincense, and myrrh. It’s the myrrh that trips people up. Common wrong third answer: “incense” , which is funny because frankincense is literally a type of incense.
37. “Away in a Manger” is often attributed to Martin Luther. Is this attribution accurate?
I’ve seen confident churchgoers get burned by this one.
Show Answer
No. Despite being subtitled “Luther’s Cradle Hymn” in some hymnals, there’s no evidence Martin Luther wrote it. The attribution appears to be a 19th-century American myth. The actual author remains unknown.
Lyrics Under a Microscope
38. In “Deck the Halls,” what does “Don we now our gay apparel” mean?
This one always gets a laugh, but the actual answer is a nice little vocabulary lesson.
Show Answer
“Don” means to put on (clothing), and “gay apparel” means festive, joyful clothing. So: put on your holiday outfits. The word “don” is the opposite of “doff” (to remove), and both date back to the 14th century.
39. Complete this lyric from “Santa Baby”: “Santa baby, slip a _____ under the tree for me.”
People sing this song every year and still fight about this word.
Show Answer
“Sable.” As in a sable fur. Eartha Kitt’s 1953 original is a masterclass in playful materialism. The requests escalate from there , a convertible, a yacht, the deed to a platinum mine.
40. In “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year,” what specific scary activity is mentioned?
This is the lyric that confuses people every single year. It’s become a meme and for good reason.
Show Answer
“There’ll be scary ghost stories.” Yes, ghost stories. At Christmas. It sounds wrong but it’s actually a reference to a Victorian tradition of telling ghost stories on Christmas Eve. Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol” is essentially one of these.
41. What color is Christmas in Elvis Presley’s famous holiday single?
Breather question. Let people relax.
Show Answer
Blue. “Blue Christmas” was released in 1957. Elvis didn’t actually want to record it , his producer, Steve Sholes, pushed for it.
42. In “I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus,” where exactly is Mommy kissing Santa?
People always say “under the mistletoe” and they’re right. But the more specific location detail is what I’m after.
Show Answer
Underneath the mistletoe, but the child sees this while “creeping down the stairs” , or, more precisely, the child “saw Mommy kissing Santa Claus underneath the mistletoe last night.” The song was recorded by 13-year-old Jimmy Boyd in 1952 and was briefly banned by the Catholic Church in Boston for mixing sex and Christmas.
43. “You’re a Mean One, Mr. Grinch” , who provided the singing voice for the 1966 TV special?
Almost everyone gets this wrong, and they get it wrong in the same way.
Show Answer
Thurl Ravenscroft. Not Boris Karloff, who narrated the special and voiced the Grinch’s speaking parts. Ravenscroft wasn’t even credited on the original broadcast. He’s better known as the voice of Tony the Tiger (“They’re Gr-r-reat!”).
44. In “Twelve Days of Christmas,” how many total gifts are given across all twelve days?
Mathematicians love this one. Everyone else starts counting on their fingers and gives up.
Show Answer
364 gifts. Each day’s gifts repeat on subsequent days, so: 1 + 3 + 6 + 10 + 15 + 21 + 28 + 36 + 45 + 55 + 66 + 78 = 364. One for every day of the year except Christmas itself.
45. What are the “five golden rings” in “The Twelve Days of Christmas” most likely referring to?
This answer has started actual arguments at my events. People don’t want to accept it.
Show Answer
Most historians and musicologists believe they refer to ring-necked birds (such as ring-necked pheasants), not jewelry. The first seven gifts in the song are all birds, which makes the jewelry interpretation break the pattern. But try telling that to someone who’s been imagining gold rings their entire life.
Around the World in Christmas Songs
46. “Feliz Navidad” by José Feliciano is notable for being sung in how many languages?
The answer is simpler than people think, and that simplicity is the whole point.
Show Answer
Two , Spanish and English. The genius of the song is that it switches between them so naturally that it became one of the most universally singable Christmas songs ever written. Feliciano has said he wanted to create something that could unite people regardless of language.
47. “Stille Nacht” (Silent Night) was declared an intangible cultural heritage by what international organization in 2011?
This one feels like it should be obvious, but people second-guess themselves.
Show Answer
UNESCO. The song’s composition and the tradition surrounding it were recognized as part of Austria’s intangible cultural heritage.
48. What Japanese Christmas song tradition involves eating fried chicken from KFC?
Not technically a song question, but it’s connected to one of the most successful Christmas marketing campaigns in history.
Show Answer
The KFC “Kurisumasu ni wa Kentakkii” (Kentucky for Christmas) campaign, launched in 1974, made eating KFC a Christmas Eve tradition in Japan. The jingle and associated music became as much a part of Japanese Christmas as any carol. People order weeks in advance.
49. The Welsh carol “Deck the Halls” , what is its original Welsh title?
Welsh speakers have an unfair advantage here. Everyone else is guessing.
Show Answer
“Nos Galan” , which translates to “New Year’s Eve.” The melody dates back to the 16th century in Wales, and it was originally a New Year’s song, not a Christmas one. The English “Deck the Halls” lyrics weren’t written until the 1860s.
50. What country’s tradition inspired “O Tannenbaum” (O Christmas Tree)?
The song is German. But the tradition it references goes deeper than most people know.
Show Answer
Germany. “Tannenbaum” means fir tree, and the song celebrates the evergreen’s faithfulness , its leaves (needles) don’t fall in winter. The melody has been borrowed for state songs, school songs, and political anthems around the world, including “Maryland, My Maryland” and the Labour Party anthem “The Red Flag.”
The Stories Behind the Songs
51. “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer” was created as a marketing gimmick for what department store?
Every character has an origin story. Rudolph’s is more corporate than people expect.
Show Answer
Montgomery Ward. Robert L. May, a copywriter at the store, created Rudolph in 1939 for a coloring book giveaway. The song came later, in 1949, written by May’s brother-in-law Johnny Marks and recorded by Gene Autry.
52. What personal tragedy was Robert L. May experiencing while he created the story of Rudolph?
This is the kind of context that changes how you hear a children’s song.
Show Answer
His wife was dying of cancer. May created the story of an outcast who becomes a hero while sitting at her bedside. She passed away shortly before the book was published. The story of a misfit finding acceptance was deeply personal.
53. “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” was originally written with much darker lyrics. What was the original opening line?
Judy Garland refused to sing the original version to a child on screen. That should tell you something.
Show Answer
“Have yourself a merry little Christmas, it may be your last.” The original lyrics by Hugh Martin were far bleaker, including lines about the future being uncertain and friends potentially being gone. Garland insisted they be softened for the 1944 film “Meet Me in St. Louis.” Years later, Frank Sinatra asked Martin to lighten the lyric “until then we’ll have to muddle through somehow” to “hang a shining star upon the highest bough.” Martin obliged, and that became the standard version.
54. Chuck Berry’s “Run Rudolph Run” was originally credited to him and what other songwriter, leading to decades of legal disputes?
The music industry and Christmas songs have a complicated relationship.
Show Answer
Johnny Marks, who also wrote the original “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer” song. The songwriting credits on “Run Rudolph Run” have been disputed for decades, with Marvin Brodie also claiming co-writing credit. The legal tangles around Christmas song royalties could fill a book.
55. What classic Christmas song was written by a Jewish songwriter who never celebrated Christmas and reportedly wrote it while feeling homesick?
Multiple Christmas classics were written by Jewish songwriters, so this could go a few ways. The specific detail about homesickness narrows it.
Show Answer
“White Christmas” by Irving Berlin. Berlin, born Israel Beilin in Russia, wrote what became the most iconic Christmas song ever. He reportedly wrote it while missing New York during a stay in Beverly Hills. The song is less about celebrating Christmas than about missing somewhere you can’t be , which is why it resonated so deeply with soldiers overseas during World War II.
56. What 1984 UK charity single brought together artists under the name Band Aid, and who organized it?
We touched on this earlier, but the full story deserves its own question.
Show Answer
“Do They Know It’s Christmas?” organized by Bob Geldof (of the Boomtown Rats) and Midge Ure (of Ultravox) to raise money for the Ethiopian famine. It featured Bono, George Michael, Sting, Boy George, Phil Collins, and many others. It became the fastest-selling single in UK chart history at the time.
The Deep Cuts
57. What instrument does the narrator play in “The Little Drummer Boy”?
It’s in the title. But I include it because sometimes the obvious question is the right one to ask after a string of hard ones. Let people breathe.
Show Answer
A drum. “Pa rum pum pum pum.” The song was originally titled “Carol of the Drum” and was written by Katherine Kennicott Davis in 1941.
58. What Christmas song mentions “a hop, skip, and a jump” and features a character threatening to return?
The threatening return is the key detail here.
Show Answer
“Frosty the Snowman” , the final lyric is “But he waved goodbye, saying, ‘Don’t you cry, I’ll be back again someday.'” Frosty melts but promises to return. It’s basically a benevolent horror movie premise.
59. In 2019, what song finally reached #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 for the first time, 25 years after its release?
We covered this earlier in the set, but it’s worth asking directly because the number , 25 years , is the part that sticks.
Show Answer
“All I Want for Christmas Is You” by Mariah Carey. The streaming era finally gave it the chart mechanism to reach #1. It’s now hit #1 every December since, essentially becoming an annual chart event. Carey has earned the unofficial title “Queen of Christmas” , which she actually tried to trademark.
The Last Song of the Night
60. “I’ll Be Home for Christmas” was written from whose perspective, and what does the final line reveal about the entire song?
I save this one for last because the answer lands differently once you know it. Every time I’ve asked it, the room gets quiet.
Show Answer
It’s written from the perspective of a soldier overseas during World War II. The final line , “I’ll be home for Christmas, if only in my dreams” , reveals that the entire song has been a fantasy. The soldier isn’t coming home. Every promise in the song , the snow, the mistletoe, the presents on the tree , is imagined. Bing Crosby first recorded it in 1943, and it became the song most requested by troops stationed abroad during the war. Knowing that, you can’t unhear it. The song isn’t about going home. It’s about knowing you can’t.
Written from the perspective of a WWII soldier overseas. The final line, "if only in my dreams," reveals the entire song is a wish, not a plan. The soldier isn't coming home.
Music and film rounds are where trivia nights either come alive or fall flat. I've been writing them in Munich, Germany for 10 years, and I believe a good music question should make everyone at the table feel something, even when they get it wrong.
Latest posts by Luca Klein, Music Journalism Cert.
(see all)
